What to watch after Stranger Things

Just finished Stranger Things? Watch The Haunting of Hill House — same subject: sci-fi & fantasy, mystery. Also strong: Supernatural, Westworld. Three lenses, each with a reason.

Best match

  1. The Haunting of Hill House (2018) — Same subject: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Mystery Streaming on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads in the US (via JustWatch)
  2. Supernatural (2005) Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Peacock Premium, Amazon Prime Video with Ads in the US (via JustWatch)
  3. Westworld (2016) — Same subject: Sci-Fi & Fantasy, Mystery
  4. Unsolved Mysteries (1987) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, Peacock Premium in the US (via JustWatch)
  5. Gravity Falls (2012) Streaming on Disney Plus in the US (via JustWatch)

Same feel, new subject

  1. Are You Afraid of the Dark? (1990) — Same feel: mysterious, suspenseful Streaming on Paramount+ Amazon Channel in the US (via JustWatch)
  2. The X-Files (1993) — Similar rhythm across its run Streaming on Hulu in the US (via JustWatch)
  3. Unsolved Mysteries (1987) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, Peacock Premium in the US (via JustWatch)
  4. Wayward Pines (2015) — Similar rhythm across its run Streaming on Hulu in the US (via JustWatch)
  5. Kolchak: The Night Stalker (1974) — Same feel: mysterious, suspenseful Streaming on Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus in the US (via JustWatch)

Same people

  1. I Am Not Okay with This (2020) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads in the US (via JustWatch)
  2. The Perfect Couple (2024) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads in the US (via JustWatch)
  3. Dash & Lily (2020) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads in the US (via JustWatch)
  4. Shadow and Bone (2021) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Netflix, Netflix Standard with Ads in the US (via JustWatch)
  5. Unsolved Mysteries (1987) — Shawn Levy produced both Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, Peacock Premium in the US (via JustWatch)

Open this answer in OpenTakes — queue picks, say "not for me", get more per lens.